Greenbelt VS. Brownfield land: a comparison of the two land types for housing
Demand for housing is at an all-time high. For many years, there has been an ongoing debate about where new housing should be built and whether it should be on green belt or brown belt land.
Green belt land makes up 1,638,150 hectares of land in the UK, while brown belt land only makes up 28,000 hectares (statistics from gov.uk).
But which is better for building?
What is Green belt land?
Green belt land acts as a divider between urban and rural areas. Green belt policy is a planning tool, and the goal of the green belt policy is to avoid urban sprawl by leaving land permanently open. The green belt land policy was introduced in 1947, by Town and Country planning to protect the countryside to control the post-war urbanisation of towns and cities.
Drawn map of England, showing greenbelt land (source credit: landmark information group Ltd)
What is brownfield land?
Brownfield land is defined as, previously developed land that’s no longer being utilised. Imagine a vacant or unused factory or industrial complex. This is land that has previously been developed or somehow changed by human activity (but does not include farmland).
Green Belt Land and Brownfield Land, which is better for housing?
This is a debate that has been going on for years. Some people believe brown belt land should be used for housing, as it is already developed and won’t spoil green belt land. However, others believe the green belt is more viable for development because they don’t believe green belt land needs to be protected, as most of it is unsuitable for wildlife.
Some of the pros of building on a green belt include:
Green belt is classed as virgin land which means it is easier to build on. It requires less groundwork preparation on the site
Construction on these sites can be faster due to no previous infrastructure
No clean-up is needed on the site, as there are no hazardous materials
It allows for population growth in new areas, which means communities can thrive
Whilst the disadvantages:
The loss of green belt land is irreversible and will negatively impact the environment
It is never popular to develop on green belt land, there will always be people who have an opinion, negative or positive
There will be greater demand for rural roads, utility networks and amenities, which might already be running at capacity
It protects the quality of human life in the area by preventing urban sprawl caused by cities, protecting people from air pollution
Greenbelt land with housing. Image: Adobe Stock Image
Whilst it may seem clear-cut to build on brownfield land, it may not always be the case. There are many advantages and disadvantages to building on this type of land.
Advantages of building on brown belt:
Sites are already in urban areas which may need more housing and amenities
Brown belt land can be bought cheaply
There are already services such as electricity, gas, water, and drainage either on the site or nearby
Good infrastructure is readily available, with roads and rail links nearby and often with good public transport links
Brownfield land can be part of a larger regeneration area, meaning there will be grants or financial incentives to redevelop it.
There is a brownfield first policy (an informal Government policy, designed to encourage developers to build on brownfields where possible), enabling planning permission to be easier to obtain
Sites are less likely to receive any objections, as local people would like to see the area improved
Disadvantages of building on brownfield:
Many brownfield sites will require demolition, site clearance or groundworks before any developments can be done, and this can be expensive
The land can be contaminated with toxic material or waste depending on the previous uses
The designs and developments may have to take into consideration existing buildings or foundations of previous buildings.
Any underground services may need redirecting or updating
During the time the site has been left abandoned, it may have become an important habitat for wildlife
There are 58 times fewer brownfields than green belt sites.
There are good arguments for and against building on both green belt and brown belt land, but there is no correct answer. It all comes down to making informed decisions on where the site is located and the condition of the land at the time of pre-planning.
Geospatial surveyors can provide you with key information for decision-making on whether the land is suitable for building housing developments or other infrastructure
As land surveyors, we can’t tell developers what land to build on, but we can help them make informed decisions. By supporting developers with topographic surveys, measured building surveys and underground utility detection surveys, we can provide all the spatial and underground services data needed to support planning applications. Our involvement won’t just be at the start of the construction journey. We will work on the project throughout its lifecycle and support all construction projects with setting out buildings as well as as-built surveys during and at the end of construction, to ensure everything is being built to standard and correctly.
If we can support you with any topographical surveys or underground utility surveys for your housing development, contact us on 01928 734473 or email [email protected]
“No two sites are ever the same - that’s what keeps it exciting.”
Sophie’s Super-Powers
Etiam eget erat facilisis, fermentum neque quis, accumsan sem. Donec rhoncus commodo libero, id viverra arcu venenatis in. Praesent ultricies massa a orci vehicula, nec elementum nisl placerat.
Nunc venenatis orci quis ligula iaculis lobortis. Sed nec est non neque blandit egestas eget ac nisl. Phasellus ut lorem neque. Aliquam erat volutpat. Integer at ante leo.
Praesent vestibulum ex et mollis viverra. Morbi eget lectus vehicula, rhoncus velit sed, accumsan purus. In sapien sapien, blandit sit amet egestas id, iaculis a mauris. Phasellus volutpat finibus metus a molestie. Aliquam placerat orci nec cursus auctor. Sed tristique in nulla sit amet rhoncus.
Jay Patel,
Apprentice
“I’m learning from day one, and I get to use the latest tech on real projects.”
Sophie’s Super-Powers
Etiam eget erat facilisis, fermentum neque quis, accumsan sem. Donec rhoncus commodo libero, id viverra arcu venenatis in. Praesent ultricies massa a orci vehicula, nec elementum nisl placerat.
Nunc venenatis orci quis ligula iaculis lobortis. Sed nec est non neque blandit egestas eget ac nisl. Phasellus ut lorem neque. Aliquam erat volutpat. Integer at ante leo.
Praesent vestibulum ex et mollis viverra. Morbi eget lectus vehicula, rhoncus velit sed, accumsan purus. In sapien sapien, blandit sit amet egestas id, iaculis a mauris. Phasellus volutpat finibus metus a molestie. Aliquam placerat orci nec cursus auctor. Sed tristique in nulla sit amet rhoncus.
Sophie Turner,
Senior Surveyor
“No two sites are ever the same - that’s what keeps it exciting.”
Sophie’s Super-Powers
Etiam eget erat facilisis, fermentum neque quis, accumsan sem. Donec rhoncus commodo libero, id viverra arcu venenatis in. Praesent ultricies massa a orci vehicula, nec elementum nisl placerat.
Nunc venenatis orci quis ligula iaculis lobortis. Sed nec est non neque blandit egestas eget ac nisl. Phasellus ut lorem neque. Aliquam erat volutpat. Integer at ante leo.
Praesent vestibulum ex et mollis viverra. Morbi eget lectus vehicula, rhoncus velit sed, accumsan purus. In sapien sapien, blandit sit amet egestas id, iaculis a mauris. Phasellus volutpat finibus metus a molestie. Aliquam placerat orci nec cursus auctor. Sed tristique in nulla sit amet rhoncus.
Insights
Greenbelt VS. Brownfield land: a comparison of the two land types for housing
Demand for housing is at an all-time high. For many years, there has been an ongoing debate about where new housing should be built and whether it should be on green belt or brown belt land.
Green belt land makes up 1,638,150 hectares of land in the UK, while brown belt land only makes up 28,000 hectares (statistics from gov.uk).
But which is better for building?
What is Green belt land?
Green belt land acts as a divider between urban and rural areas. Green belt policy is a planning tool, and the goal of the green belt policy is to avoid urban sprawl by leaving land permanently open. The green belt land policy was introduced in 1947, by Town and Country planning to protect the countryside to control the post-war urbanisation of towns and cities.
What is brownfield land?
Brownfield land is defined as, previously developed land that’s no longer being utilised. Imagine a vacant or unused factory or industrial complex. This is land that has previously been developed or somehow changed by human activity (but does not include farmland).
Green Belt Land and Brownfield Land, which is better for housing?
This is a debate that has been going on for years. Some people believe brown belt land should be used for housing, as it is already developed and won’t spoil green belt land. However, others believe the green belt is more viable for development because they don’t believe green belt land needs to be protected, as most of it is unsuitable for wildlife.
Some of the pros of building on a green belt include:
Whilst the disadvantages:
Whilst it may seem clear-cut to build on brownfield land, it may not always be the case. There are many advantages and disadvantages to building on this type of land.
Advantages of building on brown belt:
Disadvantages of building on brownfield:
There are good arguments for and against building on both green belt and brown belt land, but there is no correct answer. It all comes down to making informed decisions on where the site is located and the condition of the land at the time of pre-planning.
Geospatial surveyors can provide you with key information for decision-making on whether the land is suitable for building housing developments or other infrastructure
As land surveyors, we can’t tell developers what land to build on, but we can help them make informed decisions. By supporting developers with topographic surveys, measured building surveys and underground utility detection surveys, we can provide all the spatial and underground services data needed to support planning applications. Our involvement won’t just be at the start of the construction journey. We will work on the project throughout its lifecycle and support all construction projects with setting out buildings as well as as-built surveys during and at the end of construction, to ensure everything is being built to standard and correctly.
If we can support you with any topographical surveys or underground utility surveys for your housing development, contact us on 01928 734473 or email [email protected]
Main image source: Canva